YES
Termination Proof
Termination Proof
by ttt2 (version ttt2 1.15)
Input
The rewrite relation of the following TRS is considered.
| 
a(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b(b(x0)) | 
| 
a(b(x0)) | 
→ | 
c(c(x0)) | 
| 
b(c(x0)) | 
→ | 
a(a(x0)) | 
Proof
1 String Reversal
        Since only unary symbols occur, one can reverse all terms and obtains the TRS        
        
| 
a(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b(b(x0)) | 
| 
b(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
c(c(x0)) | 
| 
c(b(x0)) | 
→ | 
a(a(x0)) | 
1.1 Dependency Pair Transformation
          The following set of initial dependency pairs has been identified.
          
| 
a#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b#(x0) | 
| 
a#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b#(b(x0)) | 
| 
b#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
c#(x0) | 
| 
b#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
c#(c(x0)) | 
| 
c#(b(x0)) | 
→ | 
a#(x0) | 
| 
c#(b(x0)) | 
→ | 
a#(a(x0)) | 
1.1.1 Reduction Pair Processor with Usable Rules
        Using the linear polynomial interpretation over the arctic semiring over the integers
| [b#(x1)] | 
 =  | 
0 · 
                    x1 + 
                -∞
             | 
| [b(x1)] | 
 =  | 
1 · 
                    x1 + 
                -∞
             | 
| [a#(x1)] | 
 =  | 
0 · 
                    x1 + 
                -∞
             | 
| [c#(x1)] | 
 =  | 
0 · 
                    x1 + 
                -∞
             | 
| [a(x1)] | 
 =  | 
1 · 
                    x1 + 
                -∞
             | 
| [c(x1)] | 
 =  | 
1 · 
                    x1 + 
                -∞
             | 
            together with the usable
            rules
| 
a(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b(b(x0)) | 
| 
b(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
c(c(x0)) | 
| 
c(b(x0)) | 
→ | 
a(a(x0)) | 
            (w.r.t. the implicit argument filter of the reduction pair),
          
          the
          pairs
| 
a#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b#(b(x0)) | 
| 
b#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
c#(c(x0)) | 
| 
c#(b(x0)) | 
→ | 
a#(a(x0)) | 
          remain.
        1.1.1.1 Reduction Pair Processor with Usable Rules
        Using the linear polynomial interpretation over (4 x 4)-matrices with strict dimension 1 
            over the arctic semiring over the integers
| [b#(x1)] | 
 =  | 
| 0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
  · 
                    x1 + 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
 
 | 
| [b(x1)] | 
 =  | 
| 0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
  · 
                    x1 + 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
 
 | 
| [a#(x1)] | 
 =  | 
| 
                -∞
             | 
0 | 
0 | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
  · 
                    x1 + 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
 
 | 
| [c#(x1)] | 
 =  | 
| 0 | 
1 | 
0 | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
  · 
                    x1 + 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
 
 | 
| [a(x1)] | 
 =  | 
| 0 | 
1 | 
0 | 
1 | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
  · 
                    x1 + 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
 
 | 
| [c(x1)] | 
 =  | 
| 
                -∞
             | 
1 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
0 | 
                -∞
             | 
0 | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
1 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
| 0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
 
  · 
                    x1 + 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
| 0 | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
                -∞
             | 
 
 
 | 
            together with the usable
            rules
| 
a(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b(b(x0)) | 
| 
b(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
c(c(x0)) | 
| 
c(b(x0)) | 
→ | 
a(a(x0)) | 
            (w.r.t. the implicit argument filter of the reduction pair),
          
          the
          pairs
| 
a#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
b#(b(x0)) | 
| 
b#(a(x0)) | 
→ | 
c#(c(x0)) | 
          remain.
        1.1.1.1.1 Dependency Graph Processor
The dependency pairs are split into 0
        components.